The 5 best hidden restaurants in New York

Clandestine restaurants are taking over New York’s late night scene, and it’s easy to see why. It’s one thing lining up for elbow room at the latest secret bar, but it is quite another being shown to your table, like a celebrity, where an epic drinks list and menu await.

You may have to book your table days (or weeks) in advance, but trust us; it’ll be worth it. Here’s our round up of the best hidden restaurants in and around the Big Apple.

Beauty & Essex

Located inside a working pawnshop, this hip Lower East Side restaurant has several levels of chandeliers, lush couches, intimate tables and beautifully prepared Japanese-inspired dishes (try the Chile Salted Shishito Peppers…). The cocktails are inventive and unique, and the wine list extensive. Ask to be seated on the quiet second level for a bit of privacy, then head downstairs for an after-dinner drink.

Reserve: Two weeks ahead for weekends.

RELATED: Ten of the best hidden bars in New York

Luksus

Travel across the bridge to visit Brooklyn’s Nordic-infused Tørst craft beer bar in Greenpoint, then walk to the back of the bar and discover the small hidden dining room. There are only 20 tables, and craft beer is the only alcoholic offering, but because of their perfectly paired and presented food, they have been awarded a Michelin star. And you’ll understand why, the moment you have your first mouthful. Our tip is the $75USD food/beer pairing.

Reserve: One week ahead for tables of two, and at least three weeks ahead for tables of more.

La Esquina

Go beyond the surface to find awesome dining options. Photo: Yelp
Go beyond the surface to find awesome dining options. Photo: Yelp

For a taste of America’s southern neighbours head to this simple taco counter in Nolita. But don’t linger out the front, pop downstairs (through the kitchen) to reach the posh Mexican brasserie below; you’ll be hit by some intensely good smells, low lighting, small tables and very efficient waiters. The food is Mexican (think tacos, ceviche and margaritas) but all served up with a twist, and a side of attitude.

Reserve: Spots open 21 days beforehand.

Burger Joint

If street food is more your style, enter via the red velvet and short alley just off the 5-star Parker Meridien hotel lobby and you’ll find a perfect replica of a 1970’s burger cafe. Yep, there are red vinyl seats, retro condiments and good old classic American burgers. The fries serving is huge, so best to share, and the line is sometimes long.

Reserve: While you can’t make bookings here, the turnover is quick. Best to arrive before 8pm.

RELATED: Coffee is the new cool kid on the NYC block

Lady Mendl’s Tea Salon

Hidden restaurants aren’t just restricted to dinnertime; try exploring a Victorian-style mansion in Gramercy Park while you enjoy a five-course afternoon tea, complete with vintage china. You’ll need to reserve a table in advance and also have the address on hand as the tea salon is located in an unmarked brownstone building. Once inside you’ll be treated to antique furniture, a reserved atmosphere and tasty ribbon sandwiches, served with piping hot tea and coffee.

Reserve: At least a week in advance.